Who Should Make the Online Rules?
This article is a part of the On Tech e-newsletter. You can enroll associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related associated related associated associated related related associated related associated related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated associated associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related acceptable related related acceptable associated related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable associated related associated associated related related associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable associated related related related acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related related acceptable related related associated related related associated related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated related related associated associated related associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated related associated associated related related associated related related related acceptable related associated related related related acceptable related related related related related related related associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated related associated related related associated related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable associated related related related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated related associated related associated associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related associated related associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related associated related associated related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated associated related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated related related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related related associated related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated associated related associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated associated associated associated associated associated associated related associated related associated acceptable related related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related related associated related related associated related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated related related associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated associated associated associated related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related related related acceptable related associated related related related associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related correct acceptable right correct proper right here to amass it weekdays.
The tech companies had the acceptable to dam President Trump from their net net net pages this earlier week, and to cease doing enterprise with an app the place fairly merely merely solely fairly a substantial amount of of us had been urging violence. And I ponder they made the acceptable willpower to take movement.
But it must nonetheless make us uncomfortable that the picks of a handful of unelected know-how executives have tons impression on public discourse.
First, associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related associated related associated associated related related associated related associated related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated associated associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related acceptable related related acceptable associated related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable associated related associated associated related related associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable associated related related related acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related related acceptable related related associated related related associated related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated related related associated associated related associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated related associated associated related related associated related related related acceptable related associated related related related acceptable related related related related related related related associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated related associated related related associated related related associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable associated related related related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated associated related associated associated related associated associated related related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related associated related related associated related related associated related related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated related associated related associated associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related associated related associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related related associated related associated related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated associated related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable associated acceptable related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated related related acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related related associated related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated associated related associated associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related related related related related related related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated related acceptable associated related acceptable associated related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable related related acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated related associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related acceptable acceptable related related related acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated related associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated associated associated associated associated associated associated associated associated related associated related associated acceptable related related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated related related associated related related associated related associated related acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable related associated related related associated associated related associated associated acceptable associated associated acceptable associated associated related associated associated related associated associated associated acceptable associated associated associated associated associated acceptable associated related acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable associated associated associated associated related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable acceptable associated associated acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated related acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable related related related related related acceptable related associated related related related associated related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related related acceptable related acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related associated acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable acceptable associated acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related acceptable acceptable related correct acceptable right correct proper right here’s what occurred: Facebook froze at the very least briefly the president’s account after he impressed a mob that went on to assault the Capitol. Twitter locked his account absolutely. And then Apple, Google and Amazon pulled the plug on the (practically) anything-goes social group Parler.
Kicking Trump off
Yes, Twitter and Facebook are allowed to hunt out out for themselves who’s presumably on their suppliers and what these purchasers can do or say there. Locking an account that breaks Twitter’s pointers is relatively like a McDonald’s restaurant kicking you out for an excessive amount of who happen to don’t positioned on footwear.
Reasonable people can believe that Facebook and Twitter made the wrong decision to lock Mr. Trump’s account for fear that his words might inspire additional violence. But it is their prerogative to be the guardians of what is appropriate on their sites.
Millions of times a month, Facebook and Twitter delete or block posts or censure their users for reasons ranging from people selling knockoff Gucci products to people trying to post images of terrorist attacks or child sexual abuse. Again, people can quibble with the companies’ policies or their application of them, but having even the most basic rules is important. Almost no place on the internet or in the physical world is an absolute zone of free expression.
The app stores of Apple and Google, and Amazon’s cloud computing service, also are justified in kicking out Parler, an app that became a hub for organizing violent acts such as last week’s rampage. Parler set few limits on what people could say inside its digital walls, but its business partners decided that the app broke their rules when it didn’t act on examples of incitements to violence, include an exhortation to kill the vice president.
Should these companies get to decide?
I can think all these tech companies made the right decision in the last few days but still feel extremely uncomfortable that they are in the position of acting as a Supreme Court — deciding for billions of people what is appropriate or legal expression and behavior.
My McDonald’s example above isn’t really equivalent. Facebook and Twitter have become so influential that the choices they make about appropriate public discourse matter far more than whom McDonald’s lets in to buy a burger.
And while these companies’ rules are extensive, they are also capriciously applied and revised solely at their whim.
Plus, as the free expression activist Jillian York wrote, most people have little “right to remedy when wrong decisions are made.”
There has been lots of screaming about what these companies did, but I want us all to recognize that there are few easy choices here. Because at the root of these disputes are big and thorny questions: Is more speech better? And who gets to decide?
There is a foundational belief in the United States and among most of the world’s popular online communications systems that what people say should be restrained as little as possible.
But we know that the truth doesn’t always prevail, especially when it’s up against appealing lies told and retold by powerful people. And we know that words can have deadly consequences.
The real questions are what to do when one person’s free expression — to falsely shout fire in a crowded theater, or to repeat the falsehoods that an election was rigged, for example — leads to harm or curtails the freedom of others.
The internet makes it easier to express oneself and reach more people, complicating these questions even more.
Apple and Google are largely the only places for people to download smartphone apps. Amazon is one of a tiny number of companies that provide the backbone of many websites. Facebook, Google and Twitter are essential communications services for billions of people.
The oddity is not that we’re struggling with age-old questions about the trade-offs of free expression. The weird thing is that companies like Facebook and Apple have become such essential judges in this debate.
Before we go …
-
What happened at the Capitol defies easy explanation: Ben Smith, a media columnist for The New York Times, reflected on a former colleague at BuzzFeed who went from tailoring news for maximum attention online to becoming one of the people who stormed the Capitol last week. This man’s story shows that getting affirmation online “can be giddy, and addictive,” Ben wrote.
-
Fact-checking some of the responses to the tech gatekeepers’ decisions: The Electronic Frontier Foundation’s Jillian York, whom I quoted above, has a useful rebuttal to some of the claims being made about the actions of Facebook, Amazon and other tech companies against President Trump, Parler and others.
-
Tech gatekeepers as conduits of government censorship: Distinct from the choices of American tech companies, large mobile phone providers in Hong Kong appear to have cut off a website used by some pro-democracy protesters in the city. My colleagues Paul Mozur and Aaron Krolik wrote that this step set off fears that authorities may be adopting censorship tactics widely used in mainland China in Hong Kong, long a bastion of online freedom.
Hugs to this
I don’t know why this big and fluffy cat is on a beach. Just enjoy it.
We want to hear from you. Tell us what you think of this newsletter and what else you’d like us to explore. You can reach us at ontech@nytimes.com.
If you don’t already get this newsletter in your inbox, please sign up here.
